Oh no! Harlequin ladybirds in York!

I was out with friends feeding the ducks in the grounds of the University of York on Tuesday (23 October 2007). We were admiring a beautiful bird sculpture carved out of a dead tree when Cath suddenly pointed and said ‘Look at these lovely ladybirds!’ I took one look and my heart sank: harlequin ladybirds (Harmonia axyridis), the most invasive ladybirds on the planet! And they’d reached my doorstep …

Harlequin ladybird, York, 23.10.07

Harlequin ladybirds are from Asia. They were first sighted in Britain in 2004, and have been making their way across the country ever since (see annual spread maps). They threaten to wipe out all our native ladybird species. In August I heard they’d been spotted in my home town, York. Now I’d seen them too.

I collected up as many of them as I could (7), and took them home. There I took photos that I sent to the National Harlequin Ladybird Survey, along with data about what I had seen and where.

Harlequin ladybird, York, 23.10.07

I’ve now heard back from Dr Helen Roy of the survey. This is what she said:

“Thank you very much for your ladybird photo. You have correctly identified a harlequin, Harmonia axyridis.  This is a valuable record for our survey.

At the moment ladybirds are forming aggregations in preparation for winter – which they spend in a dormant state.  This is why they are so conspicuous at the moment.  Harlequin ladybirds characteristically spend winter in buildings and are particularly attracted to light coloured stone at this time of year.  We think this relates to their behaviour in their native range (Asia) where they head for rocky mountains to overwinter.

In the spring the ladybirds will start to emerge and again this is a time when we see lots but not as many as in the autumn because quite a few will die over the winter time.

It would be great if you could record all your future observations on-line – www.harlequin-survey.org

You may like to know that we now have confirmed records of the harlequin from many sites across southern England, East Anglia and the Midlands.  Further north there are a large number of records from Derbyshire and Cheshire and a few from Staffordshire, Humberside, Lancashire, Yorkshire and county Durham.  The harlequin has now also reached Wales, with records from Glamorgan, Monmouthshire, Pembrokeshire and Carmarthenshire.

If you would like to download a colour ladybird identification sheet from the Harlequin Ladybird Survey, go to: www.harlequin-survey.org/downloads/Ladybird%20descriptions_Info%20pack_NEW_v.5.pdf

The trouble with identifying harlequins is that they come in so many different colour patterns – over 100! (The ones I saw were the succinea form.) But the main thing that stands out is that they are big, and look unlike the ‘normal’ ladybirds you’re used to seeing. If in doubt, contact the harlequin ladybird survey people!

The question is, what to do about them? This is Dr Helen Roy of the UK Ladybird Survey again:

‘This a problem without an easy effective solution so far.  However, the following websites may give some ideas:


We do not recommend killing any ladybirds and although this is partly because of the risk of native species being misidentified as harlequins, also any that are killed will unfortunately make very little difference to the population.

Unfortunately there is currently no effective control method that will only target harlequins.  However, research is being done to try and develop one (possibly using a pheromone that only attracts this species).’

So, there we have it. Only time will tell what will happen to our native ladybirds …

Find out more about my subsequent encounters with Harlequin ladybirds here.

Anneliese Emmans Dean – info@theBigBuzz.bizwww.theBigBuzz.biz


  1. I fear that the Harlequin poses a more serious threat than those other aliens, Japanese Knotweed and Grey Squirrels. As well as our native ladybirds, they will eat a host of other insects sharing plants with them, ranging from hover-fly larva and lacewings to the caterpillars of butterflies and moths. I think the ecological problems caused by harlequins are potentially immense – spreading right up the food chain to birds and mammals.

    As it happens, I monitored an advanced guard of Harlequin Ladybirds in Derby in 2005, when huge numbers built up in the city, ahead of the general invasion spreading from the south-east – and which is now well into northern England.

    In a local park last week, scores of harlequins landed on my clothing and hair – a portent of what is to come…

    Bill Grange, Derby

  2. I would have thought for every Harlequin killed, you could be saving two of our native species. I do not relish the thought of killing Harlequins, but even if it has little impact on the species, it must be better than doing nothing.

  3. I tend to agree with you, but I think the fear on the part of the experts is that we may inadvertently kill a ladybird that isn’t a harlequin after all … Sending a photo to the Harlequin Ladybird Survey is a good way of checking ladybirds found really are harlequins. See http://www.harlequin-survey.org/

  4. Having bought a pack of native ladybird larvae to deal with some aphids as well as one of those slightly comical ladybird houses, I felt only a tinge of regret at killing a harlequin ladybird and a larva that I found in the midst of the aphid infestation. Letting them eat the aphids AND the little larvae seemed a bit too much. If I was wrong on the identification (which I doubt in this case) I am sorry, but at least there are the larvae to replace the possible loss. There are probably more of the harlequins about that I haven’t seen, of course!

    • Yes, I have to say we have far too many harlequin larvae for my liking around where I live at the moment … But apparently a parasite has started attacking harlequins here in Britain, so that’s good news. (Well, not good news for harlequins, obviously!)

  5. We have 2 pear trees in our back garden and apparently, harlequins are attracted to them. So, as a result, we’ve have harlequins all over the front and back windows and doors of our house. I sprayed them with ordinary fly spray and ahem, they all dropped like flies. I have stocked up on fly spray. Hope this helps someone out!

    • Hi Rod
      Next time you find harlequins (if there is a next time!), let me know, as there are some researchers at the University of Exeter who are collecting them, and are in need of people to send them (live!) ones. They’re particularly keen to have large quantities (which, so far thank goodness, we haven’t had). Thanks!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.